Fifeville and Tonsler Neighborhoods Historic District

Did you know?

Discoveries about the Fifeville and Tonsler Neighborhoods Historic District and its houses, each with its evidence. See all of Charlottesville.

Across the neighborhood

House by house

DiscoveryStatusEvidence and sources

223 4th St SW, Smith-Reaves House

Its upstairs windows sit right at floor level

The house has small half-height windows set just under the low roofline, so the upper story is more of an attic loft than a full floor.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the first page notes the small second-story windows set at floor level below the low roofline.

223 4th St SW, Smith-Reaves House

A single owner family kept the house for 64 years

Fannie Reaves bought the house and her family line held it far longer than any earlier owner, passing it to her daughter before it went to a nephew.

From the City survey

The handwritten ownership timeline on the fourth page gives 1920 as the start of the Reaves period, and the historical description gives the 1946 transfer to her daughter.

223 4th St SW, Smith-Reaves House

Experts could not tell whether it or its neighbor came first

The surveyor weighed the layout of the two lots, noting the neighbor at 225 had more side yard and so might be older, while this house sat more nearly in the middle of the original lot.

From the City survey

A handwritten note on the fifth page discusses which of the two houses was built first, using tax and Sanborn map evidence from 1893 and 1907.

402-406 4th Street SW

Railroad construction forced the front door to move

When railroad tracks occupied the former street right-of-way, the original north porch was dismantled and a replacement doorway was cut into the east gable wall.

From the City survey

Page 1 explains in the architectural description that laying railroad tracks along the street right-of-way caused the entrance to be shifted from the north facade to the east end.

402-406 4th Street SW

Linked with two sister houses by connecting hyphens

A later owner added two subsequent dwellings onto the parcel and linked all three residences together using enclosed connecting hyphens.

From the City survey

Page 1 states in the historical description that Lillian Funkhauser Dabney built two other houses on the lot, connecting all three with hyphens.

402-406 4th Street SW

Plotted along a planned route to Delevan Hotel

The residence originally stood at the projected junction of Fourth Street and an intended street extension leading directly to the historic Delevan Hotel.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes in the architectural description that the site initially sat at the planned western extension of Garrett Street toward the Delevan Hotel.

205 5th St SW, Brand-Edwards House

Brand sold the new house as the middle of three lots

Brand divided his tract into three equal lots and kept the two outer ones, selling the center lot with a freshly built brick dwelling on it. The buyer was Elizabeth Norris, whose son later inherited and sold the house.

From the City survey

The historical description and the handwritten deed notes quote the 1857 sale of the center lot, with a hand-drawn plat of the three lots.

205 5th St SW, Brand-Edwards House

Old maps show the front porch coming and going

Fire insurance maps show no porch at all on the front, then a small one-bay entrance porch, then none again, and finally a full-width veranda like the one standing today. The survey notes tie the last change to the same period as the rear addition.

From the City survey

A handwritten Sanborn map note lists the porch as absent in 1896, a one-bay porch in 1907, absent in 1920, and full facade in 1929.

205 5th St SW, Brand-Edwards House

A lifetime-care deed passed the house to a daughter

The house stayed in the Edwards family through a chain of life estates and deeds among a widow, her children and grandchildren. One deed was given in exchange for a promise to care for the owner for the rest of her life.

From the City survey

A handwritten deed abstract page records the 1980 transfer for a promise of lifetime care, following a 1973 family deed.

217 5th St SW, Barksdale-Coles-Hailstalk House

A stacked two-story pedimented entry porch

The front facade is distinguished by a prominent two-story entrance porch featuring square posts, balustrades on both levels, and a gabled pediment.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes in the architectural description that the house is distinguished by a small two-story pedimented entrance porch.

217 5th St SW, Barksdale-Coles-Hailstalk House

Former exterior chimneys enclosed by a rear wing

Two brick chimneys that originally rose on the outside rear wall became fully enclosed interior stacks when a two-story back wing was added.

From the City survey

Page 1 explains in the architectural description that two exterior chimneys were made central chimneys by the subsequent rear addition.

217 5th St SW, Barksdale-Coles-Hailstalk House

Additional rental cottages built in the backyard

Sometime after 1920, property owners added two detached frame cottages on the deep rear lot behind the primary dwelling.

From the City survey

Page 1 states in the historical description that two cottages in the backyard were built sometime after 1920.

301 5th St SW, Shelton-Fuller House

A son-in-law paid off the house after Shelton died

John Shelton died before he finished paying for the property, so his son-in-law Charles Fuller made the remaining payments and took the deed. The Fuller family then owned it for generations.

From the City survey

Page 1 says Fuller finished the payments and received a deed in 1896, and the deed notes on page 4 repeat that the Fry deed dates from 1876.

301 5th St SW, Shelton-Fuller House

Its road was once called Old Still House Road

The deed of trust describes the Sheltons living on the west side of a road called Old Still House Road. The land around it was being divided into house lots in the 1870s.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 1 quotes the 1876 deed of trust, and page 5 lists the lots Fry sold off that year.

301 5th St SW, Shelton-Fuller House

A fire in 1963 meant repairs to the house

A later set of building notes records repair of fire damage here. The same notes track a rear addition and a garage added around 1980 and 1981.

From the City survey

The handwritten notes on page 2 list repair of fire damage in 1963, a rear addition in 1980 and a garage in 1981.

308 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Dickerson House

One of six identical cottages built as rentals

Lilienfeld bought a single acre of open ground and put up six houses on it, apparently all to rent. Over the years each cottage was altered until it took on its own look.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 4 says tax records show six houses built before 1880, and page 2 calls this one of a group of identical workers cottages.

308 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Dickerson House

One family held the house for 85 years

A woman named Ellen Pollard bought it and left it to her sister Fannie Dickerson's family, who kept it in the family and lived in it for most of a century.

From the City survey

Page 5 says Ellen Pollard bought it in 1903, willed it to her sister's family when she died in 1930, and that it stayed in the family 85 years until a sale in 1988.

308 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Dickerson House

The cottage form was a common Charlottesville type

The basic plan was a three-room cottage with a two-story main section holding one room per floor, plus a one-story side or rear wing. Here the wing was later made two stories tall.

From the City survey

The architectural description on page 2 explains the common late nineteenth century form, and page 5 says the wing was enlarged between 1913 and 1920.

310 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Skeeter House

Six rental cottages went up on one empty lot

Lilienfeld bought a one-acre lot with no buildings on it and put up six houses to rent out. This house is one of that row.

From the City survey

The historical description says tax records show Lilienfeld built six houses on the lot before 1880, apparently as rentals.

310 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Skeeter House

The whole tract was sold off at auction in 1898

A creditor of Lilienfeld bought the entire tract at auction and promptly began selling the houses one by one. That sale is why look-alike cottages ended up in separate hands.

From the City survey

The historical description gives the 1898 auction and the purchaser's immediate sale of individual houses.

310 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Skeeter House

One family held the house for more than sixty years

The Skeeter family bought the house in 1923 and lived in it for over six decades. Their name stayed attached to it long after the builder's.

From the City survey

The handwritten history says G. W. Skeeter bought it in 1923 and his family owned and occupied it for over sixty years.

320 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Sellers House

One family has held the house since 1904

Thomas Sellers bought the house in 1904, and his family still owns it, which is how it got the Sellers half of its name. It has served as rental property again in recent decades.

From the City survey

The handwritten history says Thomas Sellers bought it in 1904 and that the family still owns it.

320 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Sellers House

The house grew by wings over time

A rear wing was added before 1904 and was extended or replaced in the 1920s, and the older side wing was later raised to two stories. The plain cottage form was stretched to fit changing needs.

From the City survey

The handwritten history says the rear wing was added before 1904 and rebuilt in the 1920's, with the side wing enlarged afterward.

320 5th St SW, Lilienfeld-Sellers House

The house was renovated by a housing program in 1978

A program known as CHIP renovated the house in the late 1970s, a time when many older Charlottesville homes were being restored. The form notes it in the history of the house.

From the City survey

The last lines of the handwritten history say the house was renovated by CHIP in 1978.

418 5th St SW, Hawkins-Wondree House

A house that may have served student dinners

A later owner is thought to have rented the house to someone who ran a dining hall for University students, cooking in the small downstairs room and serving in the large one. A surveyor's letter says she found no paperwork for this but saw no reason to doubt it.

From the City survey

The historical description names the 1904 purchase and the dining hall use; the later typed letter in the form discusses it.

418 5th St SW, Hawkins-Wondree House

Hawkins was a small-scale builder of rental houses

Allen W. Hawkins bought land west of the future Ridge Street and put up a number of houses on it, apparently to rent out, while selling off lots from time to time. This house was one of several he built.

From the City survey

The historical description says he bought land in 1829 and 1830 and built houses between 1832 and 1840, then bought more land.

418 5th St SW, Hawkins-Wondree House

Pothooks turned up inside a closed-up fireplace

The single small room on the main floor was probably the original kitchen, and its fireplace had been closed up. The Wondrees found cooking pothooks inside it when they opened it.

From the City survey

The architectural description, in both the 1970s form and the earlier landmark survey sheet, records the pothooks found behind the closed fireplace.

327 6th St SW, Benjamin Tonsler House

The house belonged to the head of Jefferson School

Tonsler led Jefferson School, the second public school for Black students in the city, from the year it opened until his death. He lived in this house for 38 years.

From the City survey

The historical description and significance statement on page 1 give his term as principal from 1895 to 1917, and page 3 repeats it from another source.

327 6th St SW, Benjamin Tonsler House

A friend of Booker T. Washington lived here

Tonsler graduated from Hampton Institute and was a friend of Booker T. Washington. After he died, more than a thousand people came to a memorial service for him.

From the City survey

The significance statement on page 1 records the Hampton education, the friendship and the memorial service following his death in 1917.

327 6th St SW, Benjamin Tonsler House

A city park a block away carries his name

Tonsler Park, at Cherry Avenue and Fifth Street, was named in his honor. It sits only one block from the house where he lived.

From the City survey

Page 1 says the park is named for him and lies one block from the house.

204 7th St SW, Hawkins-Lee House

Built on land that once belonged to the Delevan Hotel

Hawkins bought a piece of the Delevan Hotel property in 1869 and later put up a row of three brick houses on it, of which this cottage was the middle one.

From the City survey

Historical description on page 1 (purchase in 1869, ACDB 64-170, and the group of three houses).

204 7th St SW, Hawkins-Lee House

Brick in a city of frame cottages

The survey notes that cottages of this kind were very common in the city around the turn of the century, but almost all of them were built of wood; this one and its neighbor survive as brick examples.

From the City survey

Opening sentences of the architectural description on page 1.

204 7th St SW, Hawkins-Lee House

One family's home for half a century

Edmond Lee bought the cottage in 1902, and the Lee family owned and lived in it until his children sold it in 1955.

From the City survey

Historical description on page 1 and the deed notes on page 4 (DB 13-295 dated 11/25/1902; DB 189-416 dated 12/22/1955).

208 7th St SW, Hawkins-Parker House

Built in brick when most cottages like it were frame

Small worker's cottages of this kind were common across the city by the turn of the century, but nearly all were wooden. This one and its neighbor are the last two of a brick group of three.

From the City survey

The opening of the architectural description on page 1 notes the group of three and that almost all others of the type were frame.

208 7th St SW, Hawkins-Parker House

The land was once part of the Delevan Hotel property

Hawkins bought his lot in 1869 out of a section of the Delevan Hotel property, a tract along the Virginia Central Railroad. He later put up three brick houses there.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 1 and the 1869 deed note on page 5 describe the purchase from the Delevan property near the railroad.

208 7th St SW, Hawkins-Parker House

One family lived here for 77 years

Whit H. Parker agreed to buy the house in 1902 and got his deed in 1908, and his family went on to occupy it for 77 years. The house passed through his widow to her son, Reuben Murray, before it was sold in 1979.

From the City survey

Page 1's historical description gives the 1902 contract, 1908 deed and 77 years of family occupancy, and the deed notes on page 4 trace the will to Murray and his death in 1979.

224 9th St SW, Nalls House

A contractor bought three lots and built several buildings at once

Jacob Nalls, a building contractor, bought three lots at this corner and put up several buildings there right away. His house was one of them.

From the City survey

The historical description on the first page says he bought three lots in 1885 and built several buildings immediately.

224 9th St SW, Nalls House

Even the family name was spelled two ways

The nearby street is called Nalle Street, but the surveyor concluded the family name was properly Nalls. No one in the city still used that name at the time of the survey.

From the City survey

The historical description on the first page discusses the Nalls and Nalle spellings; the handwritten deed notes use Nalle for the street.

224 9th St SW, Nalls House

A later owner ran a grocery on the back of the lot

After buying the property from the Nalls family, Dennis Mowbray lived in the house and ran a grocery in a building facing the side street. He later kept the store while renting out the house.

From the City survey

The historical description gives the 1924 purchase and the 1929 sale of the store, and the handwritten deed sketch shows a store and garage on the lot.

300 9th St SW, Moore-Wingfield House

Faux Mansard facade masks a traditional shed roof

Carpenters created a fashionable Second Empire silhouette by installing a patterned tin Mansard facade in front of a standard sloping shed roof.

From the City survey

Page 1 explains in the architectural description that the roof presents a low patterned tin Mansard facade concealing a shed roof behind it.

300 9th St SW, Moore-Wingfield House

Louvered air vents simulate dormer windows

While front dormers hold single-pane glass windows, the three matching dormers on the side roof contain louvered air vents.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes in the architectural description that three matching dormers along Nalle Street have louvered air vents instead of windows.

300 9th St SW, Moore-Wingfield House

Elaborate Eastlake woodwork decorates the veranda

The one-story front veranda features bracketed Eastlake posts, a decorative frieze, and sawn balusters.

From the City survey

Page 1 describes the detailed veranda with an Eastlake frieze, bracketed Eastlake posts, and a sawn balustrade.

312 9th St SW, King-Burgess House

King Street takes its name from this dwelling

The adjoining roadway King Street was named in recognition of the King family, who developed this corner residential site.

From the City survey

Page 1 opens the architectural description by stating that the house is the one from which King Street takes its name.

312 9th St SW, King-Burgess House

Built by the founders of a longtime florist business

Luther King established a major greenhouse and flower business on Fourteenth Street that subsequently operated for fifty years as Page Florist.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes in the historical description that Luther King ran a greenhouse and florist shop later occupied for half a century by Page Florist.

312 9th St SW, King-Burgess House

Owners later erected a grander Queen Anne mansion

After living in this modest vernacular dwelling, the King family constructed a far more elaborate Victorian home on Fourteenth Street in 1891.

From the City survey

Page 1 records in the historical description that the Kings built their prominent Fourteenth Street house in 1891.

501 9th St SW, Oak Lawn

Oak Lawn was once called Oak Grove

James Fife, described as a businessman, farmer and Baptist minister, bought the house in 1847 and changed its name from Oak Grove to Oak Lawn. His family kept the house and a core of land even as farm lots were sold off.

From the City survey

The third paragraph of the Statement of Significance records Fife's 1847 purchase and the renaming.

501 9th St SW, Oak Lawn

A Williamsburg house served as its design model

The nomination names the Randolph-Semple House in Williamsburg as the prototype for Oak Lawn's design.

From the City survey

The first sentence of the Statement of Significance identifies the Randolph-Semple House as the design prototype.

501 9th St SW, Oak Lawn

Its farmland became the site of a junior high school

The City of Charlottesville condemned the rest of the Oak Lawn acreage in the late 1960s for Buford Junior High School, leaving the house with only five acres when the nomination was written.

From the City survey

The end of the Statement of Significance describes the condemnation for Buford Junior High School in the late 1960s and the five acres left.

501 9th St SW, Oak Lawn

A family graveyard sits beside the house

The Bramham family burial ground adjoins the property, with stones for Nimrod Bramham, his wife and a young physician in the family. Later Bibb and Simpson relatives are recorded there too.

From the City survey

The Bramham Graveyard transcription sheet in the form lists the stones, and the newspaper clipping says the graveyard adjoins the Fife one.

501 9th St SW, Oak Lawn

The old pasture became a school site

Part of the estate's pasture was sold off for Buford Middle School, and the survey map marks the Oak Lawn site next to it. What was once a large country tract is now hemmed in by city streets.

From the City survey

The newspaper clipping quotes the owners on selling the pasture, and the hand-labelled tax map shows the site beside the school.

501 9th St SW, Oak Lawn

An architecture professor ranked it the best building outside UVA

A memo to the family compares the house to a Williamsburg dwelling and to Belmont, the only other similar house in the city. He notes that Belmont has since been altered by raising its wings.

From the City survey

The typed University of Virginia School of Architecture memorandum in the form gives this assessment.

402 Dice St, Barksdale-Totty House, or The Grove

The brickwork hints the house is younger than its deed

A sale record says a house already stood on the tract, yet the brick pattern points to construction after the Civil War. The surveyor suggests the standing house may have replaced an earlier one, or that a second house once stood nearby.

From the City survey

The historical description compares the 1857 deed with the brick bonding and map evidence.

402 Dice St, Barksdale-Totty House, or The Grove

The Grove was named under a later owner

The place was known as the Totty Cottage property and then The Grove after Thomas Totty owned it. Later buyers cut the four-acre tract into smaller lots, leaving the house on a fraction of it.

From the City survey

The historical description names Totty as owner from 1863 to 1867 and traces the later subdividing.

402 Dice St, Barksdale-Totty House, or The Grove

One family kept the house for about half a century

After the Barksdale family sold in 1911, the house was bought in 1912 by a new family that kept it for fifty years or so. It then became rental property.

From the City survey

The historical description gives the 1911 sale, the 1912 purchase and the family home lasting half a century.

406 Dice St, Tyree Thomas House

Detailed woodwork echoes grand Ridge Street mansions

While located among modest vernacular cottages, this house alone displays ornate gabled window hoods and console brackets comparable to larger homes on nearby Ridge Street.

From the City survey

Page 1 observes in the architectural description that this house alone exhibits Victorian detail comparable to the larger homes on Ridge Street.

406 Dice St, Tyree Thomas House

Porch roof notched around a window hood

Because the bellcast veranda was built after the original facade, carpenters had to cut the porch roof directly around an existing window cornice.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes in the architectural description that the porch roof covers the cornice and is cut around the window cornice in the west bay.

406 Dice St, Tyree Thomas House

A two-story porch with an open upper gallery

A multi-level porch was constructed along the side of the rear addition, retaining an open upper gallery accented with Victorian railings.

From the City survey

Page 1 describes a two-story porch on the addition whose first level was enclosed while the second level remained an open porch with a Victorian balustrade.

410 Dice St, Thomas-Carr House

A relative sold Elijah Thomas half a lot to build on

Tyree Thomas split a lot he had bought, and sold the northern half to Elijah Thomas, noting that Elijah had built a house there that very year. The deed wording is the clearest proof of when the house went up.

From the City survey

The historical description and the deed notes quote the 1875 deed, and the lot purchase appears in a deed from 1871.

410 Dice St, Thomas-Carr House

A Vinegar Hill clothier bought the house and his family stayed

George M. Carr, who ran a clothing store on Vinegar Hill, bought the house at auction in 1912. It stayed in his family for about half a century.

From the City survey

The historical description names Carr, his clothing store and the 1912 sale; the handwritten deed page records the 1912 auction purchase.

410 Dice St, Thomas-Carr House

Old fire maps show the house growing a front porch

Both sections of the house already appear on the 1907 map, but the front porch is missing then, as it is on neighboring houses. It shows up on the 1920 map, and the house looked as it does now by 1929.

From the City survey

A handwritten Sanborn map note lists the porch as absent in 1907, present in 1920, and in its present form by 1929.

412 Dice St, Ferrell House

A son built a second house right next door

Patrick Ferrell's son Harrison put up a house at 414 Dice Street, next to his father's older one. The Ferrell family kept the older house for over four decades.

From the City survey

The historical description says Harrison H. Ferrell built next door in 1894, and a handwritten note on the third page counts the Ferrell years as 1882 to 1925.

412 Dice St, Ferrell House

The house was first dated by what the deed left out

Tax records showed no buildings on the lot in 1875, but the deed of 1882 mentioned improvements. That gap is how the surveyor bracketed the construction date.

From the City survey

The historical description cites tax records with no improvements as late as 1875 and the 1882 deed that mentions improvements.

513 Dice Street, Shackelford-Bannister House

House faces west toward a neighbor instead of the street

The house looks toward the undeveloped Delevan property rather than Dice Street, and the surveyor notes that a continued Sixth Street would have passed in front of it. Cinderblock steps on the Dice Street end suggest a later attempt to turn it toward the street.

From the City survey

The historical description in the typed survey form explains the westward orientation and the Sixth Street remark; the architectural description mentions the Dice Street steps.

513 Dice Street, Shackelford-Bannister House

Lot was bought for another man and had a 20 foot alley

A researcher's deed notes say the 1860 purchase from James Fife was made for R. T. W. Duke, and that a 20 foot alley was taken off the south side. The note carries a question mark about the south side.

From the City survey

Handwritten deed notes headed ACDB 59-101 and 1860 on the page of chain-of-title entries.

513 Dice Street, Shackelford-Bannister House

One family owned the house for about sixty years

After the Shackelford family sold in 1889, William and Sallie Bannister bought the house in 1905 and held it until 1965. A researcher's tally of years labels that stretch as rental property.

From the City survey

Typed historical description gives the 1889, 1905 and 1965 transfers; the handwritten summary of ownership spans lists the Bannister years as rental property.

604 Dice St, C. D. Goodloe House

Japanese influence shapes the Craftsman Bungalow design

Surveyors highlighted the residence as a Japanese-inspired variation of the Bungalow style, evidenced by deeply concave porch flairs and landscaped yard pergolas.

From the City survey

Page 1 states in the architectural description that the house represents the Japanese variation of the Bungalow style.

604 Dice St, C. D. Goodloe House

Half-timbered gables and monitor dormers

The roof features clipped gable ends decorated with faux half-timbering alongside raised monitor dormers on each side.

From the City survey

Page 1 describes clipped gables with half-timbering and monitor dormers with paired windows.

604 Dice St, C. D. Goodloe House

Diagonal glass panes set into batten door

The entrance door is assembled from vertical battens and pierced by a distinctive diagonal arrangement of three small square glass lights.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes in the architectural description that the batten entrance door has a diagonal arrangement of three small lights.

618 Dice St, Houchens-Diggs Cottage

One of five rental houses on a single tract

Houchens bought the land in two pieces and put up several small houses on it. His will told his executors to sell one or more of the five.

From the City survey

The historical description names land bought in 1881 and 1882 and a will of 1889 mentioning five houses.

618 Dice St, Houchens-Diggs Cottage

Deeded to the woman who cared for the owner's parents

After Charles Taylor bought the house, he later deeded it to Sarah J. Diggs, who had looked after his parents in their old age. Her name stuck to the cottage.

From the City survey

The historical description gives the 1891 purchase and the deed ten years later.

618 Dice St, Houchens-Diggs Cottage

A fire damaged the cottage long before its rehab

The house was damaged by fire, and the surveyor saw layers of wall and roof coverings that suggest repairs. Aluminum windows were added in the modern rehabilitation.

From the City survey

The historical description notes a fire in 1959, and the architectural description lists the layered coverings.

1022 Grove St, Gardner-Mays Cottage

The railroad is said to have paid for cottages like this

According to the form, the railroad reportedly financed a group of matching three-room cottages for workers in Fifeville during the 1890s. Their only real difference was whether the one-storey wing sat behind the house or beside it.

From the City survey

The opening sentence of the Historical Description on the landmark survey and the later typed write-up says this about the 1890s cottages.

1022 Grove St, Gardner-Mays Cottage

A rental house with one long stretch of owner occupants

The cottage was mostly a rental, but Charles J. and Ada L. Mays owned it and lived in it themselves from 1947 to 1967.

From the City survey

The Historical Description names Charles J. and Ada L. Mays as owners and occupants for the 1947 to 1967 period.

1022 Grove St, Gardner-Mays Cottage

The house once carried a different street number

Before its present number, this cottage was 1212 Grove Street.

From the City survey

The street address line on the identification block and the Historical Description both give 1022 as formerly or originally 1212.

632 W Main St, Delevan/First Baptist Church

Eight hundred members left to found their own church

The congregation began when the 800 Black members of the Charlottesville Baptist Church asked for, and received, permission to form a separate church during the Civil War.

From the City survey

The opening of the Historical Description gives the 1863 petition by the 800 Black members.

632 W Main St, Delevan/First Baptist Church

The church stands where the Mudwall hotel once stood

The congregation first worshipped in the basement of the Delevan Hotel, a temperance hotel built by General John H. Cocke of Bremo, then bought the building, and after it was condemned it was torn down and this church was begun on the spot. Locals called the old hotel the Mudwall after the rammed-earth wall that surrounded its grounds.

From the City survey

The Historical Description dates the hotel to the 1820s, records the congregation's purchase in 1868 and the demolition in 1876, and explains the Mudwall nickname.

632 W Main St, Delevan/First Baptist Church

A hotel that became a hospital and a school

Before it was a church home, the old Delevan Hotel had also housed a classical school, served as a military hospital during the Civil War, and held a free school for Black students after the war.

From the City survey

The Historical Description lists these uses of the hotel building before the congregation bought it in 1868.

417 Oak St, Lilienfeld-Truehart House

One landlord built six rental houses on a single lot

Lilienfeld bought one lot on Fifth Street and, according to tax records, put up six houses there, all apparently for renting. The tract was later sold off and the houses were sold one at a time.

From the City survey

The Historical Description page says six houses were built before 1880 on a lot bought in 1876.

417 Oak St, Lilienfeld-Truehart House

A creditor bought the whole tract at auction

Lilienfeld's land was sold at auction to cover several deeds of trust, and the buyer was one of the men he owed. That buyer began selling the houses off separately right away.

From the City survey

The Historical Description page gives the auction in 1898 and names the buyer as one of the creditors.

417 Oak St, Lilienfeld-Truehart House

The Truehart family held this house for 64 years

J. J. Truehart bought the house and his family kept it for 64 years, renting it out for a while after his death. The next owners lived in it for about two decades.

From the City survey

The Historical Description page states the Truehart purchase in 1902 and the sale out of the family in 1968.

Around town