Wertland Street Historic District

Did you know?

Discoveries about the Wertland Street Historic District and its houses, each with its evidence. See all of Charlottesville.

Across the neighborhood

House by house

DiscoveryStatusEvidence and sources

1001 Wertland St

Maps and tax records give different clues to its date

A later survey notes that the house shows up on the 1929 Sanborn map but not the 1920 one, while the City's tax parcel database dates it to 1922.

From the City survey

The Significance Statement of the 1996 reconnaissance report, repeated in the handwritten field notes, cites the 1929 and 1920 Sanborn maps and the 1922 tax parcel date.

1001 Wertland St

A corner lot raised above 10th St. NW

The 1996 survey describes the house on a corner lot set above 10th St. NW, with a high poured concrete retaining wall on the east, a smaller wall and picket fence along Wertland St., and a stone retaining wall beside the driveway on the west.

From the City survey

The Site Description in the 1996 reconnaissance report describes the corner lot and its walls and fence.

1005 Wertland St, Mix-Johnson House

Home of a city schools superintendent with a school named for him

James G. Johnson, who served as Superintendent of City Schools, made this house his home from the mid-1910s until the mid-1930s; Johnson Elementary School was named for him.

From the City survey

The Historical description on the 1998 page places Johnson here from the mid-1910s to the mid-1930s and notes the school named for him.

1005 Wertland St, Mix-Johnson House

A doctor was living here in 1895

The 1895 city directory lists Dr. O. G. Mix at this house, and the 1996 survey adds that W. G. Mix, his wife, lived here with him that year.

From the City survey

The Historical description cites the 1895 City Directory, and the Significance Statement in the 1996 reconnaissance report names both Mixes at this address that year.

1005 Wertland St, Mix-Johnson House

A garage with corrugated metal walls and doors

The surveys describe a one-story, gable-fronted frame garage at the end of the driveway behind the house, sided and fitted with doors of corrugated metal, apparently from the 1920s.

From the City survey

The Architectural description and the 1996 Relationship of Secondary Resources entry both describe the garage as apparently from the 1920s.

1009 Wertland St, Ward-Brown-Gay House

Three families in about ninety years

The 1974 survey says the house had been home to just three families: Aaron W. Ward, who built it; Mosie H. Brown (Mrs. B. A. Brown), who bought it after Ward's death; and the Gays, who bought it from her heirs.

From the City survey

Historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey sheet (page 1), citing the 1889 purchase, the 1900 sale and the 1937 sale.

1009 Wertland St, Ward-Brown-Gay House

Built on a lot from the William Jeffries estate

Ward bought Lot 4 in the subdivision of the William Jeffries estate in 1889 and built the house on it that same year.

From the City survey

Historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey sheet (page 1), citing City Deed Book 1-223 for the 1889 purchase.

1009 Wertland St, Ward-Brown-Gay House

The east wing may have come later

Surveyors read a break in the roofline as a sign that the east wing was added after the main house, though it already shows on the 1907 Sanborn insurance map.

From the City survey

Historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey sheet (page 1), which cites the roofline and the 1907 Sanborn map, backed by the alterations note on the DHR form (page 6).

1021 Wertland St

The porch steps were moved to one side

The survey notes that the front steps were taken away from the porch and set at its west side instead.

From the City survey

Last lines of the architectural description on the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form (page 1).

1023 Wertland Street

Two front doors hint at a duplex

The house has two front entrances, each with a transom, and a later surveyor took them as a sign that it was built as a duplex or turned into one early on.

From the City survey

Significance statement and description on the DHR reconnaissance survey form (page 5).

1023 Wertland Street

Part of the front porch was closed in

The earlier survey notes that the porch was once L-shaped, but one arm had been enclosed and fitted with new windows.

From the City survey

Architectural description on the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form (page 1).

1023 Wertland Street

A stone wall with quartzite piers lines the sidewalk

The later survey records a partial stone retaining wall with quartzite piers running along the sidewalk in front of the house.

From the City survey

Site description on the DHR reconnaissance survey form (page 4) and the field form notes (page 8).

1100 Wertland St, Graham House

A professor's family lived here into the 1970s

The house was probably built by University of Virginia professor W. Patton Graham, and his family stayed in it until the 1970s.

From the City survey

The Historical Description on the 1998 City survey pages says Graham's family lived there until the 1970s.

1100 Wertland St, Graham House

Three surveys, three different style labels

One state form called the house Colonial Revival, a 1996 state form called it Bungalow/Craftsman, and the 1998 City survey listed it as Vernacular.

From the City survey

The style appears as Colonial Rev. (written over Classical) on the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form, as Bungalow/Craftsman on the 1996 reconnaissance form, and as Vernacular on the 1998 data sheet.

1100 Wertland St, Graham House

A bricked-up opening on the front

A state survey form noted that an opening in the center bay of the second story had been filled in with brick.

From the City survey

The last line of the typed architectural description on the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form records the bricked-over opening.

1107 Wertland St, Marshall-Dabney-Shackleford-Cubbage House

A law professor bought the house with its stables

In 1895 Marshall sold the lot, along with the dwelling, stables and a wood house, to Walter D. Dabney, who taught law at the University.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey page records the 1895 sale to Dabney and the buildings included.

1107 Wertland St, Marshall-Dabney-Shackleford-Cubbage House

Once a convalescent home

Ann H. Cubbage, one of a group of later buyers, ran a convalescent home in the house for a time before it was split into four apartments.

From the City survey

The 1974 historical description, continuing into the Graphics box, and the 1996 significance statement both note the convalescent home.

1107 Wertland St, Marshall-Dabney-Shackleford-Cubbage House

The house once had a different street number

The survey notes that this house at 1107 Wertland Street was formerly numbered 1103.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey page gives the former number in parentheses after 1107.

1115 Wertland St

A classical doorway on a concrete block building

This flat-roofed concrete block building has its entrance in the central bay on the west side, framed by pilasters and topped with a pediment.

From the City survey

The Architectural description lists the concrete block walls, the west-side central entrance and the pedimented doorway with pilasters.

1120 Wertland St, Marshall-Edwards House

Its builder first bought 15 acres and divided them into lots

In 1892 George B. Marshall bought the McKennie-Miller House along with 15 acres and subdivided the land. He then probably built this house at what was then numbered 1114 Wertland Street.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 City form and the later typed form cites City DB 3-176 for the 1892 purchase and gives the former number 1114.

1120 Wertland St, Marshall-Edwards House

The house changed hands five times in two years

After Mrs. Annie W. McFarland's heirs sold the house in 1917, it changed owners five times in two years. In 1919 A. Evelyn Scribner bought it, later married Samuel W. Edwards, and apparently enlarged the rear wing.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 City form gives the 1917 sale, the five quick sales and the 1919 purchase (DB 34-68).

1120 Wertland St, Marshall-Edwards House

A staircase that curves almost into a spiral

Inside, a three-flight open-well stair with rounded corners turns nearly like a spiral, with a square newel and turned balusters.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the 1974 City form describes the staircase.

1121 Wertland St

The Baker family at this address

A city directory places several members of the Baker family at 1121 Wertland in 1895, presumably in this house, and the state survey names it the Baker House.

From the City survey

The 1996 reconnaissance significance statement cites the Baker family at this address in 1895, and the bibliography lists Prout and Fyler's 1895 directory.

1121 Wertland St

A long tie to the Hill family

A handwritten statement on the survey says the house's long association with the Hill family adds to its significance.

From the City survey

The handwritten Statement of Significance on the 1996 reconnaissance form page mentions the Hill family.

1121 Wertland St

Classical details that may have come later

The house mixes Queen Anne features such as shingled gables with classical touches like Ionic porch columns, and a surveyor suggested the classical details may be an early alteration.

From the City survey

The 1996 reconnaissance description and significance statement describe the mix of elements and the possible early alteration.

1200 Wertland St, T. W. Bailey House

Its builder was a partner in a local grocery firm

T. W. Bailey was a partner with H. M. Gleason in Gleason & Bailey, a firm with grocery stores on Main Street and at the Corner.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1980 City form names the firm and its store locations.

1200 Wertland St, T. W. Bailey House

The Bailey family moved back in, one apartment each

After T. W. Bailey's death the house was rented out until the early 1930s, when Mrs. Bailey took the first-story apartment and her son T. Dallas Bailey the one above.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1980 City form says the house was rental property until the early 1930s and then names who moved into each apartment.

1200 Wertland St, T. W. Bailey House

A second front door leads straight to the stair hall

Besides the main door in the center bay, another door in the western bay opens onto the stair hall. Because that bay steps back, the two doors give each other some privacy.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the 1980 City form describes the western bay entrance and says the arrangement appears to be original.

1201 Wertland St, McKennie-Miller House

A dovecote set into the front gable

One survey of the house records a dovecote built into its front gable, and the photograph on that form shows small openings high in the gable.

From the City survey

Architectural description and photograph on the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form (page 1).

1201 Wertland St, McKennie-Miller House

The Miller family kept the house for 58 years

Mrs. Mozelle Williams Miller bought the house in 1919, it stayed in the Miller family for 58 years, and Richard G. Miller, Jr. restored it.

From the City survey

Historical description on the typed survey (top of page 4), which gives the 1919 purchase (DB 32-478).

1201 Wertland St, McKennie-Miller House

Stoves, not fireplaces, heated most rooms

The survey says most rooms were first heated by stoves, and the house has just one fireplace, with a simple Greek Revival mantel.

From the City survey

Architectural description on the typed survey (page 3).

1205 Wertland St, Lewis-Lammey House

The builder left the house to her daughter Julia

When Alice B. Cochran Lewis died in 1917, her will passed the house to her daughter Julia, who sold it to W. P. Lipscomb in 1919.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 City form, repeated on the later typed form, gives her death in 1917 (City WB 2-97) and Julia's sale in 1919 (DB 32-270).

1205 Wertland St, Lewis-Lammey House

Spools in the gable peaks form a Palladian window pattern

Steep gables rise over all three of the house's projections, and the peak of each is trimmed with spools laid out like a Palladian window.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the 1974 City form and the later typed form mentions the spool-decorated gable peaks.

1205 Wertland St, Lewis-Lammey House

Paired Tuscan columns carry a veranda around the southwest corner

The one-story veranda, reached by three steps, wraps the southwest corner, and its slender Tuscan columns stand in pairs on square paneled pedestals.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the 1974 City form describes the veranda, its steps, corner and coupled columns.

1206 Wertland St, Watson House

A widow's rooming house on Wertland Street

Jennie J. Watson, widow of W. A. Watson, bought the lot and built the house, and at one time she kept a rooming house there; her daughter Hallie V. Watson later lived in the second-story apartment.

From the City survey

Historical description on the 1980 city survey (page 3), which gives the 1904 lot purchase and the 1905 building.

1206 Wertland St, Watson House

A garden temple built from salvaged Greek Revival parts

As of the later survey, a small brick garden temple stood at the back of the lot, put together from Greek Revival pieces taken from a house that had stood on West Main Street; the survey credits Walter W. and Nancy H. Reynolds, owners from 1962 to 1971, with building it.

From the City survey

Secondary resources note on page 7 and significance statement on page 8 of the DHR reconnaissance form, which give the 1962 to 1971 ownership.

1212 Wertland St, Bryan-Stallings House

Mary Bryan bought the lot behind the house she lived in

In 1893, while living in the Livers House, Mary R. Bryan bought the lot directly behind it on Wertland Street so she could build a home for herself there.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey page cites the 1893 deed and its stated purpose.

1212 Wertland St, Bryan-Stallings House

A local tradition links the house to Georgia O'Keefe

According to local tradition, the artist Georgia O'Keefe lived in this house during the 1910s.

From the City survey

The significance statement on the 1996 reconnaissance form reports this tradition, placing her there in the 1910s, and refers to the discussion for 1110 Wertland.

1212 Wertland St, Bryan-Stallings House

Betty Stallings sold the house, then bought it back

Betty Stallings bought the house in 1920, sold it the following year, and bought it back in 1931.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1974 Landmark Survey page lists the 1920 purchase, the sale a year later, and the 1931 repurchase with deed book references.

1213 Wertland St

A fraternity house before it became apartments

From the late 1930s into the early 1950s the house served Phi Beta Pi as its fraternity house, and once the fraternity left it was split into apartments c. 1951.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1998 typed form gives the late 1930s to early 1950s fraternity use and the c. 1951 conversion.

1213 Wertland St

A Peoples National Bank officer once lived here

T. E. Powers, an officer of Peoples National Bank, lived here from c. 1910 to c. 1930.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1998 typed form names Powers and gives c. 1910 to c. 1930.

1213 Wertland St

The front suggests a long veranda that old maps say never existed

A full entablature carried to the ends of the facade and the pairs of French doors make it look as if a one-story veranda once spanned the front. The Sanborn maps show the house only ever had a one-bay entrance porch.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the 1998 typed form discusses this impression and cites the Sanborn maps.

1250 Wertland St

A house that became a land company's office

The state survey form gives the building's common name as deButts Land and Management Co. and lists its use as commercial, and a sign with that name hangs over the porch in the survey photo.

From the City survey

The common name and present use fields of the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form, and its photo, show the company name.

1250 Wertland St

Probably built together with the two houses to its west

This house and its two neighbors to the west were probably all put up c. 1921-1925, judging from Sanborn maps and city directories.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1998 City form dates the three houses together to c. 1921-1925.

1250 Wertland St

A wraparound veranda gave way to a small pedimented porch

An L-shaped veranda that once wrapped the east side was replaced by a one-bay pedimented porch on Tuscan columns, and a large 40-pane picture window took the place of the paired first-story windows. A second front door was also added, so the west bay now has two.

From the City survey

The state form notes the removed L-shaped porch, the 40-pane window and the added western door, and the 1998 City form describes the replaced veranda.

1252 Wertland St

Once known as Red Gate Interiors

A state survey form gave the house the common name Red Gate Interiors and listed its use at that time as commercial.

From the City survey

The Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form shows Red Gate Interiors as the common name and commercial as present use, and the 1996 reconnaissance form lists The Red Gate Interiors as a current name.

1252 Wertland St

A foursquare under a front-gable roof

Surveyors pointed out that the house pairs the American foursquare form with a gable-front roof, a mix they called unusual.

From the City survey

Both the 1998 City architectural description and the 1996 reconnaissance description name this combination.

1252 Wertland St

A vanished front porch left its footings behind

A one-story front porch seems to have been taken off, leaving a concrete floor and brick bases for its columns, though the Sanborn maps do not show such a porch.

From the City survey

The 1998 City architectural description notes the removed verandah and the Sanborn maps, and the 1996 form also records the leftover porch column bases.

1254 Wertland St

Built along with its two neighbors to the east

Sanborn maps and city directories suggest this house and the two houses east of it were probably all built between about 1921 and 1925.

From the City survey

The Historical Description on the 1998 City survey dates all three houses to c. 1921-1925 from Sanborn maps and city directories.

1254 Wertland St

An apartment complex rose in the back yards

In 1998 an apartment complex was built in the back yards behind this house.

From the City survey

The last sentence of the Historical Description on the 1998 City survey records the 1998 apartment complex.

1256 Wertland St, Hearathstone House

The brick house was moved around the corner

The house first stood at 110 Thirteenth Street, NW, and was moved to its Wertland Street site in 1998.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1998 City form gives the original address and the 1998 move.

1256 Wertland St, Hearathstone House

A children's house took its name from a tourist home

At mid-century the house served for many years as a tourist home. From 1982 to c. 1992 it held the Hearthstone Children's House, named after that tourist home, and then its successor, the Ronald McDonald House.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1998 City form covers the tourist home and the 1982 to c. 1992 use.

1256 Wertland St, Hearathstone House

A state survey form lists this address as a parking lot

The Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form filed with the City survey records 1256 Wertland Street as vacant and used for parking.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the state survey form reads vacant, parking lot for 1256.

1301 Wertland St, Wertenbaker House

The builder left out the stair to his own dining room

According to his great-granddaughter, William Wertenbaker planned the house himself but forgot an inside stair down to the basement kitchen and dining room, so the household had to step outdoors to reach meals. The stair was apparently never added.

From the City survey

The architectural significance section of the older state survey form reports this from Mrs. Alicia Flynn, described there as the builder's great-granddaughter.

1301 Wertland St, Wertenbaker House

Wertland Street was named for this house

The house itself was known as Wertland, and the street it stands on took its name from it.

From the City survey

The older state survey form gives the historic name as Wertland and says the street was named for the house.

1301 Wertland St, Wertenbaker House

An early woman doctor and medical missionary owned the house

Prof. Milton Humphreys bought the house from Charles Christian Wertenbaker, and his daughter, Mrs. Edward R. Dyer, later owned and lived in it. The form calls her one of the earliest women doctors and says she spent time as a medical missionary in the Orient.

From the City survey

The historical significance section of the older state survey form names Humphreys and Mrs. Dyer and describes her work.

1306 Wertland St

Apartments known as George Rogers Clark Apts.

The state survey form gives the common name of this apartment group as George Rogers Clark Apts.

From the City survey

The Common name field at the top of the Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form reads George Rogers Clark Apts.

1306 Wertland St

A longer twin on 13th Street

The building at 113-117 13th Street NW follows the same design but is ten bays long, with two entrances instead of one.

From the City survey

The second paragraph of the architectural description says 113-117 is the same except for its 10 bays and entrances in the third bay from each end, and the second photo shows the two doorways.

1308 Wertland St

Listed under the name Division of Personality Studies

A later survey records the house under the current name Division of Personality Studies, with ownership marked public (state) and the University of Virginia's Rector and Visitors in the mailing address.

From the City survey

Property names, ownership and mailing address on the DHR reconnaissance survey report (pages 2 and 4), with the name also on the field form (page 6).

1310 Wertland St

Two surveys disagree about the corner stones

One state form describes the house's corner quoins as limestone, while another reconnaissance form says they are made of rock-faced concrete blocks.

From the City survey

The Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form lists limestone quoins, and the 1996 reconnaissance description says the quoining is formed with rock-faced concrete blocks.

1310 Wertland St

Palladian windows in both gables

The house has a Palladian window in its front gable, and the 1996 survey notes another in the rear gable.

From the City survey

The Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form notes the Palladian window in the front gable end, and the 1996 reconnaissance description lists Palladian windows in the front and rear gables.

1310 Wertland St

Parking garages on two sides

A sketched site plan shows parking garages on two sides of the house, along with a parking lot and a commercial building.

From the City survey

The hand-drawn site plan on the 1996 field form, dated 2/96, labels the parking garages, parking lot and commercial building around 1310.

Around town