Rugby Road-University Corner Historic District

Did you know?

Discoveries about the Rugby Road-University Corner Historic District and its houses, each with its evidence. See all of Charlottesville.

Across the neighborhood

House by house

DiscoveryStatusEvidence and sources

420 15th St NW, Connell Cottage

Fifteenth Street once went by a different number

The early 1890s deeds for this lot describe it as fronting on 3rd Street, not Fifteenth Street.

From the City survey

The deed abstracts on page 6 for the 1893 conveyances to Claudia M. Connell give the lot as 50 feet on 3rd St.

420 15th St NW, Connell Cottage

Deeds proved the house older than first thought

A 1983 state survey went by real estate records dating the house to 1910, but the later city survey traced the Connell deeds back to the early 1890s.

From the City survey

The 1983 state form on page 1 cites a 1910 real estate date, while the deed notes on pages 3, 5 and 6 trace Connell ownership to 1892-94.

420 15th St NW, Connell Cottage

Home of a brick company officer

R. L. Carter, who bought the house from the Connells in 1894, appears in the 1906-07 city directory as treasurer of the Charlottesville Brick Company.

From the City survey

The 1894 sale to R. L. Carter is on page 5, and the 1906-07 city directory note on page 4 lists him as the brick company's treasurer.

510 17th St NW, Moss-Johnson House

This house replaced a bigger one lost to fire

Lizzie Harmon first built an even larger house on her Preston Heights lots, but it burned in 1893 and she put up the present house in its place.

From the City survey

The historic description on page 3 gives the 1893 fire, and the tax notes on page 8 mark the building taken off the rolls for fire.

510 17th St NW, Moss-Johnson House

The house was moved and its porch trimmed to fit

The house once sat in the middle of a three-lot corner tract, but around 1933 it was moved to the northern lot, and part of its wraparound veranda was cut away so it would fit the 56-foot frontage.

From the City survey

Page 3 describes the move, probably in 1933, and the Sanborn sketches on page 5 show it shifting after 1929.

510 17th St NW, Moss-Johnson House

A Victorian family home turned student rooming house

After Grace Booker Johnson's daughter sold the house to University Corner Apartments in 1965, it became rental housing for students, and field notes call it a rooming house with twelve rooms.

From the City survey

The historic description on page 3 covers the 1965 sale and student use, and the notes on page 4 describe a twelve-room rooming house.

514 17th St NW, Steptoe House

Asbestos shingles hid the original wooden walls

In 1955 the house's weatherboard siding was covered with white asbestos shingles trimmed in green, likely erasing much of its original texture.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 1 dates the re-siding to 1955, and the notes on page 4 record asbestos shingles over wood siding.

514 17th St NW, Steptoe House

A daughter lived on in her mother's house for life

Fannie Steptoe left the house to her daughter Elizabeth for her lifetime, and city directories from 1953 list Elizabeth renting furnished rooms there.

From the City survey

Page 1 mentions the life estate, page 6 details the will, and the city directory notes on page 5 list furnished rooms in 1953.

514 17th St NW, Steptoe House

An Eastlake staircase climbs past a round window

Inside, a three-flight open-well stair in the Eastlake manner rises from the entry hall, lit by a circular window on the north wall.

From the City survey

The architectural description on page 1 and the field notes on page 8 describe the stair and its circular window.

518 17th St NW, R. M. Balthis House

Built for the manager of a longtime student bookstore

R. M. Balthis ran Anderson Brothers Bookstore, a long-lived Charlottesville shop where University of Virginia students bought their books.

From the City survey

The statement of significance in the federal certification application (page 4) describes Balthis as manager of Anderson Brothers Bookstore.

518 17th St NW, R. M. Balthis House

A widow who took in student lodgers

After Balthis died in 1925, his widow stayed on in the house for years and let out several of its rooms to students.

From the City survey

Page 1 gives his 1925 death, and the statement of significance on page 4 says his widow rented rooms to students.

518 17th St NW, R. M. Balthis House

One of the first houses in Preston Heights

Balthis bought two lots in the new Preston Heights subdivision in 1899, and his house was among the earliest built there.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 1 records the 1899 lot purchase, and page 4 calls it one of the first houses in the subdivision.

1701 Gordon Ave

Polygonal entry vestibule projects from the front

The main doorway is set into a projecting demi-hexagonal brick vestibule that forms an angular entry pavilion on Gordon Avenue.

From the City survey

Page 1 identifies the demi-hexagonal front vestibule as a curious architectural feature.

1701 Gordon Ave

Curved half-timbering accents the cross-gables

Carpenters installed curved decorative boards across the upper gables to evoke English half-timbered construction.

From the City survey

Page 1 notes that cross-gables with curved boards recalling half-timbering reflect Queen Anne styling.

1701 Gordon Ave

Brick veneer encases an older frame dwelling

Surveyors observed weatherboard siding beneath the eaves, indicating that the brick house was expanded over an older frame dwelling.

From the City survey

Page 1 explains that weatherboards visible beneath the roof suggest an older frame house was enlarged and brick-veneered.

1705 Gordon Ave

Student renters nicknamed the house The Resort

The surveyors recorded that the students living here had given the place a jokey nickname, The Resort. The form lists it as the common name.

From the City survey

The historical information box and the common name line on the survey form.

1705 Gordon Ave

Old maps narrow the build date to a 28-year window

With no deed or builder named, the surveyors dated the house by comparing Sanborn maps.

From the City survey

The historical information box says the Sanborn maps place construction between 1929 and 1957.

1508 Grady Ave, Macon Hall

This was the second house Bradberry designed for Macon

This was the second house Bradberry designed for Macon. The first stood at University Circle and was sold some years before this one went up.

From the City survey

The historical description on the typed survey form gives the 1914 build and 1919 sale of the first house.

1508 Grady Ave, Macon Hall

The garage had servants quarters upstairs and is now housing

A brick two-car garage on the property had servants quarters above it. It has since been converted entirely to living space.

From the City survey

The last sentence of the architectural description on the typed form, and a handwritten note about the garage conversion.

1508 Grady Ave, Macon Hall

Tax books show a building added to the lot

The lot was assessed alone in 1922 and then a large building value was added the next year.

From the City survey

A handwritten tax page lists 1922 and 1923 entries for Macon, with building value added in 1923.

1600 Grady Avenue, Preston Court

Apartments rose on the front yard of the Preston home

The Preston family kept a large tract around their house when the Wyndhurst estate was cut up, and in 1927 the two lots forming the house's front yard were bought for this apartment building.

From the City survey

Historical description on page 1 describes the Wyndhurst subdivision and the 1927 purchase of the front-yard lots (City DB 59-246).

1600 Grady Avenue, Preston Court

Designed by a University of Virginia architecture professor

The plans for Preston Court came from Stanislaw Makielski, who taught architecture at UVA, and the later nomination names Frank E. Hartman Co. as the builders.

From the City survey

Historical descriptions on pages 1 and 3, and the architect/builder line of the National Register form on page 8.

1600 Grady Avenue, Preston Court

Put forward for the National Register decades later

In 2007 the state's Department of Historic Resources sent the City a draft National Register nomination for the apartments, citing their architecture and social history.

From the City survey

Department of Historic Resources letter dated June 25, 2007 on page 4 and the registration form on pages 5-8, which lists Architecture and Social History as areas of significance.

1601 Grady Ave

Exterior chimney features sloping pyramidal weatherings

An unusual brick end chimney incorporates dramatic pyramidal weatherings that taper noticeably as the stack rises.

From the City survey

Page 1 highlights in the descriptive notes an odd exterior end chimney with sloping pyramidal weatherings.

1601 Grady Ave

Roof dormers face sideways rather than front

Rather than orienting toward the street, the hipped attic dormers look out toward the side elevations of the house.

From the City survey

Page 1 states in the descriptive notes that dormers face to the sides rather than the front.

1601 Grady Ave

Distyle front portico frames the side entry

The main entrance door with transom and sidelights is set at the far right bay beneath a gabled distyle Colonial Revival porch.

From the City survey

Page 1 describes a Colonial Revival distyle gabled porch sheltering an entry at the far right with top and sidelights.

1602 Gordon Ave, Dabney-Thompson House

A future president may have visited this house

Dabney was a college classmate and close friend of Woodrow Wilson, who stayed at Dabney's later home on Rugby Road. The form says Wilson probably visited this house as well.

From the City survey

The statement of significance in the later typed survey writeup mentions Wilson as a close friend and guest.

1602 Gordon Ave, Dabney-Thompson House

The author of a famous memoir was born upstairs here

Dabney's son Virginius, later a writer, was born in this house and lived here until he was six. His memoir opens with the house, and he wrote to the surveyors to confirm the building was his father's.

From the City survey

A letter from Virginius Dabney and a page of his memoir are included near the end of the form.

1602 Gordon Ave, Dabney-Thompson House

The house spent thirty years as a rooming house

After being a family home, it took in roomers for decades under one owner. Later it became a clinic, and a trailer was parked beside it for extra offices.

From the City survey

The historical description on the landmark survey page covers the rooming house use, the clinic and the trailer.

1603 Grady Ave, Alpha Delta Pi House

The house later became a sorority house

Though built as a private home, it was known at survey time as the Alpha Delta Pi house. It sits on Grady Avenue near the University.

From the City survey

The common name line at the top of the first survey page names the sorority.

1603 Grady Ave, Alpha Delta Pi House

A near twin stands next door

The surveyor found this house very like the one at 1601 Grady, with the chimney in a different spot. Here it rises from the middle of the house.

From the City survey

The miscellaneous description box on the first survey page compares it to the neighboring house and its chimney.

1603 Grady Ave, Alpha Delta Pi House

The street number on the form may be wrong

A handwritten note beside the address suggests it should read 1602 rather than 1603. Old survey forms sometimes carry numbers that differ from the building's real address.

From the City survey

A handwritten correction next to the street address on the first page of the form.

1703 Grady Ave, Sigma Alpha Epsilon Fraternity House

It may have started out as a private house

A later preservation application says W. A. Rinehart built the central block in 1920, that it was probably a private home until Sigma Alpha Epsilon bought it in 1922, and that the side wings came around 1936-38.

From the City survey

Statement of significance in the Historic Preservation Certification application on pages 3-4 (built 1920, purchased 1922, wings around 1936-38); the 1983 survey on page 1 also notes it was possibly built as early as 1927.

1703 Grady Ave, Sigma Alpha Epsilon Fraternity House

One of the first national fraternities at the University

The fraternity's Virginia Omicron chapter was founded at the University of Virginia in 1858, and the application calls it one of the first national fraternities to set up a chapter there.

From the City survey

Historical information on page 1 (chapter founded 1858) and the statement of significance on page 3.

1707 Grady Avenue, Alpha Epsilon Pi Fraternity House

A fraternity house that began as a church

The older, hip-roofed western section was built in 1929 for a Christian Science congregation, and Alpha Epsilon Pi moved in after it was converted in 1962.

From the City survey

Historical information and the descriptive notes on page 1, which give 1929 for the church and 1962 for the conversion.

1801 Lambeth Ln

Cantilevered construction angles the front walls diagonally

Rather than a conventional flat facade, the modern building uses cantilevered concrete and masonry to angle its exterior walls on the diagonal.

From the City survey

Page 1 highlights in the descriptive notes that this cantilevered concrete and brick building features front walls set on the diagonal.

1801 Lambeth Ln

Modern apartments replaced a small postwar cottage

The multi-story apartment block rose directly over the site of a modest one-story frame cottage constructed around 1952.

From the City survey

Page 1 explains in the historical notes that the complex was erected on the site of a three-room frame cottage built ca. 1952.

1811 Lambeth Ln, Theta Delta Chi House

Built by a university official to sell to a fraternity

Dr. Lambeth, the University's Director of Athletics and Superintendent of Buildings, built the house in 1914 to sell to a fraternity. Theta Delta Chi moved in during 1915 and bought it from him in 1922.

From the City survey

The Statement of significance on the National Park Service application pages gives the 1914 build, the 1915 move-in and the 1922 purchase.

605 Preston Pl, Wyndhurst

Union soldiers raided the house

During the short Union occupation of Charlottesville in March 1865, soldiers raided Wyndhurst, then owned by Thomas L. and Anna M. Preston.

From the City survey

The historical description and the significance note on the first page both record the raid during the March 1865 occupation.

605 Preston Pl, Wyndhurst

A boarding house for University students

For many years Charity S. Pitts ran a well-liked boarding house here for students at the University, and the form credits her with probably making most of the later additions.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 1 describes Mrs. Pitts's boarding house, and the state form on page 3 dates her use to about 1930 to 1970.

1417 University Ave, Spicer Brothers Cleaners

A cleaners and a record shop gave the building its names

The 1983 form lists two common names for the building, a Spicer's laundry and cleaners and Recycled Records, and the record shop's sign shows over the entrance in the survey photo.

From the City survey

Common name line and photograph on the 1983 state survey form.

1417 University Ave, Spicer Brothers Cleaners

Its tiny entry also leads down to shops below the street

From the recessed entrance, visitors could reach shops on the main floor and take stairs down to commercial spaces on the lower level.

From the City survey

General description and descriptive notes on the 1983 form, and the additions note on the later reconnaissance form.

1417 University Ave, Spicer Brothers Cleaners

The storefront bays were once open to the sidewalk

The two front bays were at first left open and were later filled in with plate glass.

From the City survey

Additions and alterations note on the later reconnaissance form.

1417 University Ave, Spicer Brothers Cleaners

A bookstore on this spot since 1852

At least one storeroom here has held a bookstore since 1852, starting with George Jones's shop and followed by Henry Massie's. R. D. Anderson bought the business in 1876, and the 1980 form called it the oldest Charlottesville business still in its original location.

From the City survey

The historical description on the 1980 survey form lists the bookstores with their years from 1852 and names R. D. Anderson's 1876 purchase.

1417 University Ave, Spicer Brothers Cleaners

The 1848 building is still at the core

Rather than tearing down Roach's building, the builders of 1891-92 put the present building up around it, so its core dates back to 1848.

From the City survey

The historical description says the present building was built around the old one in 1891-92, and the significance section says the core dates back to 1848.

1417 University Ave, Spicer Brothers Cleaners

A matching metal front on West Main Street

A smaller building at 711 West Main Street has a metal-clad front identical to one section of this one.

From the City survey

The historical description on the survey form makes this comparison with 711 West Main Street.

1427 University Ave, Sheppe Building

A drugstore site sold to Sheppe

The 1980 surveyor noted that the property was first the University Drug Store, from 1875, and was sold to Sheppe in 1891. A later survey instead suggests a grocery came first, with the drugstore there by 1912.

From the City survey

The historical significance note on the 1980 form gives 1875 and 1891, and the 1996 reconnaissance form's significance statement gives the grocery and 1912.

1427 University Ave, Sheppe Building

An older frame building may hide inside

The brick building put up in 1925-26 probably takes in an older frame building dating from 1890-96.

From the City survey

The additions and alterations section of the 1996 reconnaissance form dates the brick building to 1925-26 and the older frame building to 1890-96.

1427 University Ave, Sheppe Building

Round-arched windows once lit the front

Since the 1940s the front windows have replaced two pairs of round-arched windows, and corner piers that once rose above the parapet have been removed.

From the City survey

The additions and alterations section of the 1996 reconnaissance form describes these changes since the 1940s.

1 University Cir, Phi Delta Theta House

A fraternity house, then a home, then a fraternity house again

In 1920 the building, or one before it on the site, was the Sigma Chi fraternity house. It was a private residence in the 1950s, and Phi Delta Theta acquired it in the early 1960s.

From the City survey

The historical information on the survey form gives 1920 for Sigma Chi, the 1950s for private use, and the early 1960s for the Phi Delta Theta purchase.

10 University Cir, Raleigh Court

Designed by a builder with no formal training in architecture

C. M. Wade drew up the plans for Raleigh Court himself, and also for the other buildings put up by the firm of Wade and Failes, without any formal architectural schooling.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 1 says Wade had no formal training in architecture but designed this and the firm's other buildings.

10 University Cir, Raleigh Court

A wide band of trim scales the building to its neighborhood

A wide entablature with dentil molding runs around the whole building between the second and third story windows, meant to give it a more domestic scale among the single-family homes nearby.

From the City survey

The architectural description on page 1 explains the entablature and its purpose of fitting the building to a neighborhood of single-family homes.

10 University Cir, Raleigh Court

The name Raleigh Court is raised on the center portico

The words RALEIGH COURT appear in raised letters on the frieze of the middle portico at the first story level.

From the City survey

The architectural description on page 1 and the handwritten notes on page 8 both mention the raised lettering on the center portico.

2 University Cir, Neff House

A lot in the University Place subdivision

John H. Neff, Sr. bought this lot in the University Place subdivision in 1911 and probably built the house that same year. The 1912-13 City Directory lists his family living on University Place.

From the City survey

The handwritten historical description bundled with the form cites the 1911 deed and the 1912-13 City Directory.

2 University Cir, Neff House

A sleeping porch closed in with plywood

The two-story hipped-roof wings at the rear include an upstairs sleeping porch that was later enclosed with plywood.

From the City survey

The handwritten architectural description bundled with the form describes the rear wings and the enclosed sleeping porch.

2 University Cir, Neff House

Diamond-paned windows light the stairs

Small casement windows with diamond-shaped panes, set in the eastern bay at both levels, light the staircase.

From the City survey

The handwritten architectural description bundled with the form mentions the diamond-paned casements in the eastern bay.

3 University Cir, Hotopp-Watson House

Older than the circle it stands on

This is probably the earliest house on University Circle, built several years before the land was laid out as University Place in 1907-08. After Mrs. Hotopp's death, the whole tract was sold in 1906 to the men who developed the subdivision.

From the City survey

The state form's descriptive notes give the 1907-08 development, and the City form's historical description gives the 1906 sale to Lile, Lambeth and Alderman.

3 University Cir, Hotopp-Watson House

French doors open onto the gazebo roof

A circular gazebo sits at the west end of the veranda, and a pair of French doors on the second floor opens onto its flat roof.

From the City survey

The architectural description on the City survey form describes the gazebo and the upper French doors that reach its roof.

4 University Cir, Rugby Apts

The building's name is spelled out above its front door

The entrance under the portico has a frieze with the word RUGBY in raised letters, topped by a broken swan's-neck pediment.

From the City survey

The handwritten description of the entrance on page 3 notes the name in raised letters on the frieze and the pediment above the door.

4 University Cir, Rugby Apts

It once had a different address on University Place

Before it was known as 4 University Circle, the building was numbered 5 University Place, and an old deed calls its lot the new number 36 of University Place.

From the City survey

The heading on page 1 says formerly 5 University Place, and the deed notes on page 6 name the lot as new number 36 of University Place.

4 University Cir, Rugby Apts

Garage doors sit along the back at basement level

On the rear, the four side bays have garage doors at the basement level, with a three-story back porch and screened stair in the center bay.

From the City survey

The rear elevation notes on page 4 list the garage doors and the back porch, and a rear photo on page 7 shows them.

6 University Cir, Watson Terrace Apartments

Built for a university biology professor

The 1983 survey says these apartments were built for Thomas L. Watson, a professor of biology at the university, who lived in the house at no. 3 University Circle.

From the City survey

Historical information box on the 1983 Virginia Historic Landmarks Commission form (page 4).

6 University Cir, Watson Terrace Apartments

The Watson family kept an apartment into the 1950s

According to the 1998 survey, members of the Watson family lived in one of the apartments until the mid-1950s, and the family sold the building in 1962.

From the City survey

Historical description at the top of page 3 of the 1998 typed form gives the mid-1950s occupancy and the 1962 sale.

6 University Cir, Watson Terrace Apartments

A rear building with parking underneath was added in 1996

A two-story stuccoed building with parking below was attached to the rear additions in 1996; as of the 1998 survey it held two apartments and the original building three.

From the City survey

Architectural description on page 2 and historical description on page 3 of the 1998 form, which dates the rear building to 1996.

1520 Virginia Avenue

Miss Virginia May kept student boarders here

According to the form, Miss Virginia May lived at this house and kept students as boarders from around or before 1930 until about 1940 or later.

From the City survey

The Historical information section names Miss Virginia May and her student boarders around or before 1930 to about 1940, citing city directories, Sanborn maps and an interview.

1521 Virginia Ave

Two fraternities listed at one address in 1931

The 1931 city directory lists the house for both Nu Sigma Nu and Alpha Kappa Alpha fraternities, though the surveyor's source thought this might be an error. The form suggests it may have housed a fraternity from the start.

From the City survey

The historical information section cites the 1931 Directory listing, the note that it could be a mistake, and the possibility of fraternity use from the beginning.

1522 Virginia Ave

This house may once have been a fraternity house

According to Eugenia Bibb, the house may have been used by a fraternity in the 1920s.

From the City survey

The Historical information section credits Eugenia Bibb with the possible fraternity use in the 1920s.

1522 Virginia Ave

An oversized front door under an unusual fanlight

The entrance at the left of the front has an oversized door with sidelights and an elliptical fanlight divided by rectangular muntins, which the surveyor called an odd feature.

From the City survey

Described under Location and description of entrance and again in the Miscellaneous descriptive information section.

1530 Virginia Ave

A fraternity lost the house during the Depression

Phi Alpha fraternity was living here by 1922-23, and its house corporation, Mu Holding Associates, bought the property in 1928. The corporation lost it during the Depression.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 8 gives Phi Alpha's occupancy in 1922-23, the 1928 purchase and the loss during the Depression.

1530 Virginia Ave

A boarding house run by Anne E. Rea

Anne E. Rea bought the house in 1933 and kept a boarding house there until she sold it in 1944.

From the City survey

The historical description on page 8 says she bought it in 1933, ran a boarding house, and sold it in 1944.

1530 Virginia Ave

Once the westernmost house on its side of Virginia Avenue

When Peyton sold the lot to George Gilmer, the deed placed the house as the farthest west on the south side of Virginia Avenue.

From the City survey

The 1919 deed notes on page 5 and the historical description on pages 7 and 8 give this description of the house.

1532 Virginia Avenue

A house perched on the edge of a steep ravine

The house was built at the brink of a steep ravine, so a short walkway runs from the sidewalk to the house and the basement is reached at ground level from the back, like its neighbors on the same side of Virginia Ave.

From the City survey

The Miscellaneous descriptive information section describes the ravine, the walkway and the rear basement entry.

1533 Virginia Ave, Sigma Pi House

Two other fraternities may have lived here before Sigma Pi

Going by the city directories, the house may have been home to the Theta Chi fraternity in 1931 and to Phi Alpha in 1940.

From the City survey

The Historical information section on page 1 says it may have housed Theta Chi in 1931 and Phi Alpha in 1940, judging from the City directories.

1533 Virginia Ave, Sigma Pi House

A Sigma Pi chapter moved in after its founding

The Beta Pi Chapter of Sigma Pi Fraternity was set up at UVa in 1959 and moved into this house around 1963-65.

From the City survey

The Historical information section on page 1 gives the 1959 founding and the ca. 1963-65 move.

1533 Virginia Ave, Sigma Pi House

Iron balconies that double as fire escapes

The iron balconies below the windows served as fire escapes, and the certification application describes a black iron fire escape balcony under the portico between the two floors.

From the City survey

The Miscellaneous descriptive information on page 1 and the physical description on the Historic Preservation Certification Application both mention the iron fire escape balconies.

1536 Virginia Ave

Much bigger than it looks from the street

The house is far larger than it appears from the front, since it is entered at ground level on its west side and rear. A separate apartment entrance sits at the lower level on the west side.

From the City survey

The descriptive notes on the survey form say the house seems smaller from the street and describe the at-grade and lower-level entries.

1536 Virginia Ave

Gable end to the street, unlike its neighbors

Its gable end faces the street, which sets it apart from the other houses along this stretch.

From the City survey

The descriptive notes on the survey form contrast the front-facing gable with the neighboring houses.

1537 Virginia Ave, Delta Delta Delta House

From a medical fraternity to a sorority house

The Phi Chi medical fraternity used the house from 1927 or earlier until about 1971, and the Delta Delta Delta sorority has been there since 1971.

From the City survey

The historical information section gives Phi Chi's use from 1927 or before to ca. 1971 and the sorority's occupancy since 1971.

1537 Virginia Ave, Delta Delta Delta House

A dormer door that opens onto the portico deck

A long central dormer with a curved top leads straight out onto the deck on top of the front portico.

From the City survey

The miscellaneous descriptive notes describe the curvilinear-headed central dormer opening onto the portico deck.

1541 Virginia Ave

Records and style point to different decades

City real estate records place the house's construction between 1920 and 1930, but the surveyor thought its style looked more like the 1910s.

From the City survey

The historical information section gives the 1920 to 1930 range from real estate records and says the style suggests the 1910s.

Around town